How to pack cards for grading

The good news: every major grading company wants roughly the same thing. A soft sleeve, a semi-rigid holder, and nothing clever.

On this page
  1. The short version
  2. Why semi-rigid holders?
  3. Company by company
  4. Don't clean, press or "fix" a card
  5. Handling tips
  6. Before you pack: is it worth sending?

The short version

  1. Slide each card into a clean, clear penny sleeve.
  2. Slide the sleeved card into a semi-rigid holder, one card per holder. The common size is 3 5/16 × 4 7/8 inches, which is what a Card Saver I measures.
  3. Don't tape the holders shut, don't add stickers or pull tabs, and don't put cards in team bags.
  4. Follow the company's own packing instructions for the box itself, which come with your submission.

Why semi-rigid holders?

A semi-rigid holder protects the card in the post but flexes enough for a grader to slide the card out without forcing it. CGC puts it simply on its shipping page: the holder "must be sturdy enough to allow us to remove the card safely." A rigid toploader is harder to get a card out of, which is why several companies ask you not to use them.

Company by company

PSA

PSA's shipping guide asks for clear penny sleeves and semi-rigid holders, and says not to use toploaders, tape, pull tabs or sticky notes. It also asks for clear sleeves rather than solid or opaque ones, which slow processing down.

TAG

TAG's help centre (June 2026) asks for a soft sleeve and then a 3 5/16 × 4 7/8 semi-rigid such as a Card Saver I, and says those are required. It asks you not to send cards in toploaders, magnetic one-touch cases or screw-down holders, not to seal the semi-rigids with tape or stickers, and not to put individual cards in team bags.

CGC Cards

CGC asks for each card in a protective sleeve and then a semi-rigid sleeve. Its shipping-kit instructions add: don't use tape on the semi-rigid holders, and don't use team bags to separate cards.

Beckett (BGS)

Beckett's submission material recommends a penny sleeve and then a semi-rigid holder, and discourages screw-down holders. Beckett's site and submission process were disrupted for parts of autumn 2026, so check beckett.com for its current instructions before you send anything.

ACE Grading

ACE's help centre (August 2026) asks for a penny sleeve and a semi-rigid holder with one card per holder. It asks you not to tape holders shut, which can stick to the card in transit; not to bind cards with elastic bands, which can bend them; and not to attach pull tabs, which can leave indents. For thick cards it suggests a magnetic case.

Don't clean, press or "fix" a card

It's tempting to give a card a little help before it goes in. Resist it. Every major company checks for alteration, and an altered card doesn't get a numerical grade:

  • CGC lists trimming, restoration, power erasing, chemical cleaning, pressing and stain removal among the signs of alteration, and returns such cards without a number.
  • PSA won't grade cards showing trimming, restoration, recolouring, altered stock or cleaning. It counts crease or wrinkle pressing, scratch removal and enhanced gloss as altered stock, and any cleaning spray or wax on the surface as evidence of cleaning.
  • TAG won't grade cards it finds trimmed or altered, and its help centre warns that polishes, waxes and cleaning sprays can leave residue its system may flag as altered.
  • ACE gives an Altered grade to a card recoloured, reshaped, restored or otherwise modified, returns it raw, and still charges the fee.

In almost every case the fee is still charged. A slightly worse number is far better than no number at all.

What about dust and fingerprints? Beckett's graders have said they don't recommend preparing cards, but that a gentle wipe with a microfibre cloth to remove small smudges or fingerprints is acceptable. A soft, clean, dry cloth and a light touch is the most anyone should do. No sprays, no liquids.

Handling tips

  • Wash and dry your hands first. Skin oil leaves marks on glossy and holo surfaces.
  • Hold cards by the edges, and sleeve them on a clean, soft surface.
  • Slide the card into the sleeve top first, gently. Forcing it is how corners get dinged at the last minute.
  • Check each card one more time once it's sleeved. It's your last chance to catch a mark or a mix-up.

Before you pack: is it worth sending?

Grading costs money, so it's worth a few minutes to check a card first. Measure the centering front and back, then look closely at the corners, edges and surface. How to check a card before grading walks through it, and Preslab will measure the centering from a photo for free.

Prices, turnaround times and service levels change often, and some services pause from time to time. Check the company's own site on the day you submit.

Sources: PSA's shipping guide, TAG's help centre, CGC Cards' shipping page and shipping-kit instructions, Beckett's submission form, ACE Grading's help centre and grading scale, CGC Cards' "cards we grade" page and PSA's FAQ. Preslab is not affiliated with any grading company.

Check a card

Photograph the front and back. Preslab measures the centering and shows how high PSA, TAG, BGS, CGC and ACE let it grade. Free, and centering only.