How to check a card before grading

Grading isn't cheap, and no one enjoys paying to learn a card had a dent. Ten careful minutes at home will catch most of what a grader will see.

On this page
  1. What graders look at
  2. What you'll need
  3. 1. Centering
  4. 2. Corners
  5. 3. Edges
  6. 4. Surface
  7. Be honest with yourself
  8. Then decide

What graders look at

Every major grading company weighs the same four things: centering, corners, edges and surface. A card's grade is held back by its weakest one. Perfect centering can't make up for a soft corner, and four sharp corners can't make up for a crease. So check all four, and don't let one great feature talk you into ignoring the others.

Collectors often call this pre-grading. It isn't an official service from the grading companies, just the habit of checking a card honestly before you send it.

What you'll need

  • A bright, clean white light. CGC's graders describe using LED lamps for exactly this reason: "a nice, clean white light". A desk lamp with a daylight bulb works well.
  • A loupe or magnifier. A 10× jeweller's loupe is cheap and shows corner and edge wear your eye will miss.
  • A dark, soft cloth to lay the card on, which makes white wear stand out and protects the surface.
  • A ruler, calipers or a phone for centering.
  • Clean, dry hands. CGC's graders don't wear gloves, and explain that gloves can do more damage than you'd expect. Just wash and dry your hands and hold the card by its edges.

1. Centering

Start here, because it's the one thing you can measure exactly. Measure the border on opposite sides, left against right and top against bottom, on the front and the back. Then compare the worse direction on each side with the limit at the company you're considering. For a Gem Mint 10, PSA, CGC and TAG each allow about 55/45 on the front.

How to measure card centering explains the arithmetic, and Preslab will measure it from a photo for free.

2. Corners

Look at all four corners, front and back, under the loupe. CGC's graders describe checking corners "using a loupe", all four, "both front and back".

  • Sharpness. A mint corner has a clean, even curve. Look for any flattening, fraying or rounding.
  • Whitening. On cards with a coloured back, tiny white specks at a corner are where the ink has worn and the card stock shows. They're easiest to spot on dark backs.
  • Dings and bends. Tilt the card and look along each corner. A corner that's been bent, even slightly, catches the light differently from the rest of the card.

3. Edges

Run your eye slowly along all four edges, front and back. You're looking for:

  • white chips or nicks along the edge, especially on dark borders;
  • a rough or fuzzy edge where it should be a clean cut;
  • any dent or wave in the edge.

A little whitening along the back edges is easy to miss at arm's length and easy to see under a loupe. It's worth a careful look.

4. Surface

CGC's graders call the surface "one of the tougher areas to analyze at home", and the trick is the light. Hold the card under your lamp and tilt it slowly until the reflection of the bulb slides across the surface. Graders describe doing just this to find "wrinkles, creases, dimples and even alterations".

  • Scratches show as fine lines in the reflection. Holo and foil cards scratch easily.
  • Dents and dimples show as a wobble in the reflection, even when you can't see them straight on.
  • Creases, even hairline ones, show as a line where the reflection breaks. A crease, even a light one, takes a card well out of the top grades.
  • Print lines and specks are factory flaws, not damage, but can still cost a top grade.
  • Fingerprints and smudges are worth noting. A gentle wipe with a clean, dry microfibre cloth is as far as you should go; see how to pack cards for grading for why.

Be honest with yourself

It's easy to see what you hope to see. A few habits help:

  • Check the back as carefully as the front. Graders do.
  • If you find something under the loupe, assume the grader will find it too.
  • Compare against a card you already know is mint, if you have one.
  • Take a break and look again later with fresh eyes.

Then decide

If the centering clears your chosen company's limit and the corners, edges and surface look clean under a loupe, the card is a reasonable candidate. If centering is past the limit, you know the ceiling before you pay. And if you find a flaw, you've saved yourself a fee.

When you're ready to send, how to pack cards for grading covers sleeves, semi-rigid holders and what not to do.

Quotes are from CGC's "Grade School" videos and articles. Preslab measures centering only and shows corner crops for you to inspect; it doesn't judge corners, edges or surface. Preslab is not affiliated with any grading company.

Check a card

Photograph the front and back. Preslab measures the centering and shows how high PSA, TAG, BGS, CGC and ACE let it grade. Free, and centering only.