Why cards come out off-center

Off-center cards aren't damaged. They were born that way, at the factory, when a big printed sheet was cut into cards. Here's how it happens and what the different kinds look like.

On this page
  1. Cards start life as a sheet
  2. Left to right, top to bottom
  3. Tilts and diamond cuts
  4. Where off-center ends and a miscut begins
  5. Can you fix an off-center card?
  6. Checking yours

Cards start life as a sheet

Trading cards aren't printed one at a time. They're printed side by side on large sheets, and CGC's guide to error cards notes that a sheet typically carries 100, 110 or 121 cards. The sheets are then cut into card-sized rectangles, and the pointed corners are rounded off afterwards in a separate step with a die cutter.

The printed image and the cut are made by different machines at different moments. If the sheet sits a fraction of a millimetre off where the cutter expects it, every border on that card shifts: one side gets a little wider and the opposite side a little narrower. That's an off-center card.

A slip of half a millimetre doesn't sound like much, but a card border is only a few millimetres wide. On a pair of borders that add up to 5 mm, half a millimetre moved from one side to the other takes a card from 50/50 to 60/40.

Left to right, top to bottom

A shift can happen in either direction or both. A card shifted sideways has a wide left border and a narrow right one, or the other way round; a card shifted up or down has unequal top and bottom borders. Graders measure both directions and judge the card by the worse one, which is why a card can look fine at a glance and still be well off in one direction.

The front and the back are judged separately, and they don't always sit the same way against the cut. A centered front with an off-center back is common. Front vs back centering covers how much room each company gives the back.

Tilts and diamond cuts

Sometimes the sheet isn't just shifted but slightly rotated when it's cut. The image then sits at an angle to the card's edges: a border is wider at one end of a side and narrower at the other, and the opposite side does the reverse. Collectors call this a tilt or a diamond cut.

A tilt is harder to spot than a straight shift because the borders can average out to something close to even. Measuring each border at both ends of its side shows it. Grading companies do allow for it: CGC's grading scale, for example, allows "a very slight diamond cut" at NM/Mint+ 8.5 and more noticeable ones at lower grades.

Where off-center ends and a miscut begins

Off-center means the borders are uneven but the card is otherwise cut the way it was meant to be. A miscut is a step further: the cut is in the wrong place altogether. CGC's error guide describes the scale like this:

  • Minor miscut: at least half of an alignment dot shows in a corner, or some of the card's design is missing, but no part of the next card shows.
  • Miscut: part of at least one other card is visible.
  • Major miscut: parts of at least two other cards are visible.

CGC's guide also describes a card that went into the corner-rounding machine at an odd angle, leaving three of its rounded corners misplaced.

Grading companies label miscuts rather than just grading them lower. ACE's scale lists MC for a card cut incorrectly at the factory, and PSA uses MC on its labels for factory miscuts. Some collectors seek out dramatic miscuts as error cards, so a miscut isn't always bad news; it's just a different kind of card from a well-centered one.

Can you fix an off-center card?

No, and you shouldn't try. Trimming a card to even out its borders changes its size and is treated as alteration: grading companies look for it, and an altered card won't get a numerical grade. If a card's centering keeps it from the grade you want, the honest options are to send it to the company whose limits suit it best, keep it raw, or look for a better-centered copy.

Checking yours

A ruler or calipers will tell you a lot (see how to measure card centering), and a straight-on photo can tell you more. Preslab straightens your photo, measures the border on all four sides, front and back, and shows how high the centering lets the card grade at PSA, TAG, BGS, CGC and ACE.

Sources: CGC's error card guide and grading scale; ACE's grading scale. Preslab is not affiliated with any grading company.

Check a card

Photograph the front and back. Preslab measures the centering and shows how high PSA, TAG, BGS, CGC and ACE let it grade. Free, and centering only.