How to spot surface damage
Most surface damage is invisible straight on and obvious at the right angle. All you need is one bright lamp and a slow tilt.
On this page
Why straight on doesn't work
Looking straight down at a card, you see the printed picture, and the picture hides the surface. A scratch, a dent or a hairline crease barely changes the colours you're looking at. What it does change is how the surface reflects light. So the trick is to stop looking at the card and start looking at a reflection on it.
CGC's graders call the surface "one of the tougher areas to analyze at home", and describe doing exactly this: holding the card to a lamp and moving it until the bulb's glare crosses the surface, to find "wrinkles, creases, dimples and even alterations".
Set up
- One bright lamp with a clean white bulb, such as a desk lamp with an LED or daylight bulb. CGC's graders use LED lamps for "a nice, clean white light".
- A darkish room, so the lamp's reflection is the brightest thing on the card.
- Clean, dry hands, holding the card by its edges, or the card in a fresh penny sleeve if you'd rather not touch it. The sleeve adds its own reflections, though, so a bare card shows the surface most clearly.
The sweep
Hold the card under the lamp and tilt it until you see the bulb's bright reflection on the surface. Then tilt it slowly so the reflection travels from one edge of the card to the other. Do it top to bottom, then side to side, then on the back. It takes less than a minute a side.
A clean surface reflects the lamp as an even, unbroken patch of light. Anything that isn't flat and smooth disturbs it. Here's what to watch for.
What each kind of damage looks like
Scratches
A scratch shows as a thin line crossing the reflection, darker or brighter than the light around it, and it moves with the reflection as you tilt. Holo, foil and full-art cards scratch easily, often from being slid in and out of sleeves or across a playmat. Very light scratches may show only on the glossy surface and only at one angle, so tilt both ways.
Dents and dimples
A dent is a small dip in the card. You often can't see it at all straight on, but the reflection bends or wobbles as it passes over it, the way a reflection in a window bends over a flaw in the glass. Dents often come from a fingernail, a corner of another card, or something pressed against the card through a sleeve.
Creases
A crease is a line where the card has been bent. Even a hairline crease that has flattened again breaks the reflection along a line, with the light on one side of it at a slightly different angle from the other. Check corners closely: bends often start there. A crease, even a light one, takes a card well out of the top grades.
Print lines and print specks
Not all marks are damage. A print line is a thin line printed into the card at the factory, and specks or spots of ink can be too. They show straight on as well as at an angle, and they don't move with the reflection, because they're in the print rather than the surface. They're not your fault, but they can still cost a top grade.
Fingerprints and smudges
These show as a hazy patch or swirl in the reflection. A gentle wipe with a clean, dry microfibre cloth usually lifts them. Don't use sprays, liquids or polishes: grading companies can treat residue from them as alteration. How to pack cards for grading has the details.
Tips that help
- Go slowly. Most people miss damage by tilting too fast.
- Change direction. A scratch running along the direction you tilt can hide; sweep the other way too.
- Use a loupe for anything you're unsure about. Once you've spotted something in the reflection, a 10× loupe shows what it is.
- Check the back. It gets scratched and dented as easily as the front, and graders look at it just as closely.
- Your phone can help. A short video of the sweep, played back slowly, sometimes catches what your eye missed.
Why Preslab doesn't check the surface
A single straight-on photo is the worst possible view of a card's surface: it's the angle where damage hides. That's why Preslab measures centering only and leaves the surface to you. The sweep above, done honestly, is the best surface check you can do at home.
When you've checked the surface, corners and edges, the pre-grading checklist covers everything else before you submit.
Quotes are from CGC's "Grade School" videos and articles. Drawings are simplified illustrations, not real cards. Preslab is not affiliated with any grading company.
Photograph the front and back. Preslab measures the centering and shows how high PSA, TAG, BGS, CGC and ACE let it grade. Free, and centering only.